Twelve baits start a cast in Shroud of the Avatar: ten for water and two lures for lava. Bait decides which fish come up, never how often they bite, so pick the bait for the fish you want.
The wiki’s bait pages still promise “a bonus to catching fish”. That wording predates the October 2026 overhaul: the work log checked the catch lists and found no bait that changes the bite rate. We quote the wiki’s old notes below as “wiki says”, for what each bait was thought to favour, and we flag the one bait with a published figure.
Every water bait casts in fresh, salt and fetid water; the two lures cast only in lava. The share column is how often anglers actually chose each bait in the last 30 days before the overhaul (Catnip Games, to 2 October 2026), which says more about habit than about fish.
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 28.9%
Where to get it
Harvest wild cotton plants (not farmed ones), mostly in summer. Frogs drop one now and then.
Catch notes
The scene’s normal catch list in any water; no bait-specific pull has been published. It was the most-cast bait in the game before the overhaul.
Wiki says
common; bonus in fresh water
Minnow
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 24.2%
Where to get it
Comes up as a bait return while fishing (the community board lists “Minnow (Bait)”), or from a Jar of Minnows.
Catch notes
The scene’s normal catch list in any water; no bait-specific pull has been published.
Wiki says
common; small bonus in any water
Red Worm
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 20.3%
Where to get it
Mining a clay deposit, or a Jar of Worms.
Catch notes
The scene’s normal catch list in any water; no bait-specific pull has been published.
Wiki says
common; any water
Earthworm
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 0.3%
Where to get it
Harvesting most non-reagent crops; mining clay deposits.
Catch notes
The scene’s normal catch list in any water; no bait-specific pull has been published. In fetid water it also draws Blood Leeches, which are themselves bait (work log, 17 October 2026).
Wiki says
common; any water
Sardine
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 1.3–1.5%
Where to get it
A bait return while fishing (“Sardine (Bait)” on the community board).
Catch notes
The scene’s normal catch list in any water; no bait-specific pull has been published.
Wiki says
common; bonus in salt water, small bonus in fresh and fetid
Herring
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 1.3–1.5%
Where to get it
A bait return while fishing in salt water.
Catch notes
The one bait with a published figure: in salt water a Tiger Shark about once in 3,320 casts, once in 344 inside a chum slick. Otherwise the scene’s normal catch list in any water.
Wiki says
uncommon; large bonus in salt water, bonus in fresh and fetid
Tiny Squid
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 1.3–1.5%
Where to get it
A salt-water bait return. In game, the Oracle can tell you where to get it.
Catch notes
The scene’s normal catch list in any water; no bait-specific pull has been published.
Wiki says
rare; very large bonus in salt water, large bonus in fresh and fetid
Blood Leech
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 0.8%
Where to get it
Fished up in fetid water; cast an Earthworm there to draw them.
Catch notes
The scene’s normal catch list in any water. The wiki’s shark bonus is unconfirmed; the only published shark figure is for Herring (see the guide’s FAQ).
Wiki says
rare; very large bonus in fetid water, large bonus in salt and fresh, large bonus to sharks
Drudge Leech
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 5.3%
Where to get it
Fished up in fetid water (“Drudge Leech (Bait)” on the community board). In game, the Oracle can tell you where they come from.
Catch notes
The scene’s normal catch list in any water; no bait-specific pull has been published.
Wiki says
uncommon; large bonus in fetid water, bonus in salt and fresh, large bonus to Blood Leeches
Pale Leech
Fresh waterSalt waterFetid waterShare of casts: 1.3–1.5%
Where to get it
Fished up in fetid water (“Pale Leech (Bait)” on the community board).
Catch notes
The scene’s normal catch list in any water; no bait-specific pull has been published.
Wiki says
common; bonus in any water (the old Blood Leech bonus claim is gone)
Both lures are Alchemy recipes sold by NPC vendors and crafted at an Alchemy Station with a Mortar and Pestle. They are used up 0.6 times as often as water bait, so a lure survives about four casts in ten where a worm would be lost. Lava needs a lava-capable rod, not the Lava Fishing skill.
Gemmed Lure
LavaAlchemy 30Share of casts: 3.1%
Ingredients
2 × Chunk of Coal
100 × Gem Fragment
1 × Iron Ingot
⚒ Mortar and Pestle
Makes 10 Gemmed Lure
Where to get it
Alchemy 30: 2 Chunk of Coal, 100 Gem Fragment and 1 Iron Ingot make 10. The recipe is sold by NPC vendors.
Catch notes
Lava only. The common choice for the eight lava fish.
Bait Recovery is an innate fishing skill that opens at Fishing Proficiency 40. It is your base chance to keep the bait on a cast in water; the wiki lists it starting at +0.3% and growing with skill, a figure we have not re-checked since the overhaul. Angler rings, imbued angler jewels and the Fish Finder Cloak add to it. In lava the Ring of the Lava Angler does the same job for lures.
Gemmed lures are already lost less often than water bait, about six lures for every ten worms, before any recovery bonus.
Seventeen baits exist on paper and twelve work. Cut Bait, Leech Lure, Dough Bait, Bird Liver and Tiny Gemmed Starfish are the other five: they pass the bait checks but carry no fishing effect, so they cannot start a cast and cannot be found anywhere in the world. Nine further baits are set aside for a later economy update. Those fourteen are the items that look like bait and cannot cast.
Cut Baitcannot be obtained
Leech Lurecannot be obtained
Dough Baitcannot be obtained
Bird Livercannot be obtained
Tiny Gemmed Starfishcannot be obtained
Catnip Games said in October 2026 that the in-game guides now list the twelve working baits and name the fourteen that are not in the game yet.
Where to fish(zones by water type, player-town water, lava at home)
Fishing Report(community catches by fish and by location)
Recipes(cooking the catch, chum, the lure recipes)
Mechanics verified against Catnip Games’ fishing work log and fishing deep dive, October 2026. Species, sizes, bait and rod item facts come from the SotA wiki. Last checked 30 October 2026. Icons: SotAwiki, CC BY.